Productive Intolerance & Utilitarianism
This article examines the limits of liberal tolerance and introduces the concept of “productive intolerance,” proposing that punitive actions against intolerant groups may be justified when they protect the wider public interest.
Drawing on utilitarian ethics, it argues that sanctioning organisations that incite violence can maximise collective happiness and prevent harm. At the same time, the piece criticises Jeremy Menchik’s formulation of productive intolerance, emphasising that any restrictions on freedom must be proportionate and mindful of minority rights.
The full study appears in Jurnal Filsafat Indonesia (DOI: 10.23887/jfi.v6i2.55041).